Recently, I tried several products to extract demographic information from a profile image. My target was to obtain information about age, gender, and ethnicity. I found the prominent companies in the sector are Clarifai and Face++. I integrated my trial software with both products and I found Clarifai’s accuracy better than Face++. My reasons are:
- Clarifai provides the probability value of its predictions. (predicted gender is female with a probability %52) So, it is possible to eliminate the results having low prediction score. On the contrast, Face++ does not provide that value. This is an unwanted situation because, in binary classification technique, the prediction always has a result, even its score is not very high.
- Clarifai correctly predicted the ethnicity of the image below as “White”, while Face++ wrongly predicted it as “Black”. But on the other hand, Clarifai could not found the gender value correctly (female %51, male %49) while Face++ correctly marked it as male (we don’t know its probability).
- The disadvantage of Clarifai is its low quota for free usages. It permits only 2500 API calls per month for free accounts. But Face++ does not specify any upper limit for free accounts. It has only one single limitation, which is one single API call per second.
I hope my hands-on experience with these services will help you choose the right product.
Result of Clarifai: (https://clarifai.com/demo)
Gender: feminine (prob. score: 0.510), masculine(prob. score: 0.490)
Age: 55 (prob. score: 0.356)
Ethnicity (Multicultural appearance): White: (prob. score: 0.981)
Result of Face++: (https://www.faceplusplus.com/attributes/#demo)
Ethnicity (Multicultural appearance): Black
Also published on Medium.